Diagnostic bone biopsy

 

Home Up

Small animal section: No. 18

HOW TO GET A DIAGNOSTIC BONE BIOPSY

Histopathological examination of a bone biopsy is the diagnostic procedure of choice for bone lesions in small animals.  The two most common diagnoses, inflammation or neoplasia, may be suggested by clinical signs and radiography.  Biopsy is usually required to attain a provisional diagnosis, which may need to be confirmed by examination of the full lesion if excision or amputation follows.  Recent literature suggests that histological grading of osteosarcoma may be of prognostic significance.  Knowledge of tumour type can also determine the basis for a diagnostic plan.  Biopsy may be necessary to differentiate between benign bone tumours, metastatic tumours, degenerative or congenital lesions.  A final diagnosis often depends on consultation between the pathologist and referring veterinarian, as some lesions require combined assessment of clinical, radiographic and histopathological findings.

bullet

Open incisional biopsy: this method often provides a good large piece of tissue, and therefore a good chance of obtaining an accurate diagnosis. Complications such as an increased risk of haematoma formation, wound break down, infection, seeding of the incision with tumour cells and post-biopsy pathological fractures are all major disadvantages.

bullet

Closed needle or trephine biopsy: is the method of choice since although it does provide a smaller specimen, post-surgical complications are greatly reduced.  Both are easy, quick and safe and an accurate diagnosis can be made in up to 94% of cases.  Either a Jamshidi needle or Michelle trephine technique can be used.  With the Jamshidi bone marrow biopsy needle, the stylet can be inserted for guiding the needle through soft tissue, while the sharp tapered cutting edge allows entry into cortical bone.  The Jamshidi needle technique may have a lower risk of inducing pathological fractures.  The trephine method involves initial placement of a K-wire to pinpoint the biopsy site. 

Guidelines for obtaining a diagnostic bone biopsy:

bullet

Take more than one biopsy.  It is usually possible to obtain these through one skin incision by redirecting the biopsy needle or trephine.

bullet

Carefully locate the center of the lesion radiographically, and take biopsies from this area.  Measurements from prominent bony landmarks help pinpoint the proposed biopsy site.

bullet

Avoid dense, often peripheral, areas of reactive bone

bullet

Include both cortical and medullary bone in the samples: most tumours originate in the medullary cavity

bullet

Penetrate only one cortex, so as to reduce the risk of post-surgical fracture

bullet

Locate the skin incision in such a way that the biopsy tract, with any seeded tumour cells, can be completely removed if full surgical excision or amputation is later required

bullet

Locate the skin incision in such a way that it does not interfere with skin flaps that may be required after amputation.

Possible causes for inaccurate histological diagnosis:

bullet

Sample submitted is not representative of the pathological process (eg reactive bone or inflammation on the edge of an osteosarcoma)

bullet

Too few samples submitted – accuracy is greatly increased with multiple samples

bullet

Inaccurate typing of the tumour is common with poorly differentiated tumours as biopsy samples are often too small to obtain the necessary information. 

bullet

Extensively necrotic tumours may not yield diagnostic specimens

bullet

Crushing and squeezing of the biopsy sample can obscure cellular detail

bullet

Overdecalcification may obscure cellular detail, making histological evaluation difficult.

bullet

Osteosarcoma can be very variable, so that a morphological diagnosis of undifferentiated sarcoma, fibrosarcoma, chondrosarcoma, or haemangiosarcoma should be taken as a differential diagnosis to osteosarcoma until confirmation is obtained from the excisional biopsy specimen.

REFERENCES (Available on request): 

B E Powers, S M LaRue, S J Withrow, R C Straw, S L Richter (1988) Jamshidi needle biopsy for diagnosis of bone lesions in small animals.  Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 193:205-210

C H Tangner (1989) A modified technique for closed trephine bone biopsy Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 25: 55-56

P M Wykes, S J Withrow, B E Powers, R D Park (1985) Closed biopsy for diagnosis of long bone tumours: accuracy and results.  Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 21: 489-494

For further information contact:

VetPath Veterinary Pathologists
P.O. Box 8464
Pretoria 0001
Tel: (012)
529 8345/6
e-mail: info@vetpath.co.za

Home Up

For any animal pathology queries, please send e-mail to info@vetpath.co.za.
Questions or comments about the structure of this web site, please send e-mail to webmaster@vetpath.co.za.
Copyright © 2004 Bill Robb & Associates
Last modified: Friday June 25, 2004